It's the Fourth of July again, and I'm here to renew the campaign to replace "The Star Spangled Banner" with "America the Beautiful" once again.
This is the kind of imagery I associate with America, and this is the imagery used by "America the Beautiful". As I said a couple of years ago:
I don't like "The Star Spangled Banner". It's a chest-thumping,
militaristic poem about a particular battle early in our history, set to
a British drinking tune, which explains why it's so hard to sing - you
have to be drunk to sing it, and that rise up to the high note (... o'er the laaaaand of the freeeeee...)
was where they raised their flagons high in the pub and spilled beer
all over themselves. It doesn't say anything about the country, the
people, and what the country is all about. All it's about is barely
winning one battle. And as the character Belize says in Tony Kushner's Angels in America:
"The white cracker who wrote the National Anthem knew what he was
doing. He set the word free to a note so high nobody could reach it."
(Yes, Francis Scott Key, the "poet" who composed the lyrics, was pro
South, pro slavery, from a slave-holding family from Carroll County,
MD.)
My suggestion for a new national anthem is "America the
Beautiful". The words were written by Katharine Lee Bates, an English
professor at Wellesley College, in 1893 after a trip from Boston to
Colorado Springs. The music was composed by Samuel A. Ward, a church
organist and choirmaster. Unlike "The Star Spangled Banner", "America
the Beautiful" is meant to be sung in a reverent and respectful manner
and actually praises America for its beauty and principles. Let's face
it, it's just a much more pleasant song, both lyrically and musically,
than the current national anthem.
- O beautiful for spacious skies,
- For amber waves of grain,
- For purple mountain majesties
- Above the fruited plain!
- America! America!
- God shed His grace on thee,
- And crown thy good with brotherhood
- From sea to shining sea!
- O beautiful for pilgrim feet
- Whose stern impassion'd stress
- A thoroughfare for freedom beat
- Across the wilderness.
- America! America!
- God mend thine ev'ry flaw,
- Confirm thy soul in self-control,
- Thy liberty in law.
- O beautiful for heroes prov'd
- In liberating strife,
- Who more than self their country lov'd,
- And mercy more than life.
- America! America!
- May God thy gold refine
- Till all success be nobleness,
- And ev'ry gain divine.
- O beautiful for patriot dream
- That sees beyond the years
- Thine alabaster cities gleam
- Undimmed by human tears.
- America! America!
- God shed His grace on thee,
- And crown thy good with brotherhood
- From sea to shining sea.
So as usual in my annual campaign, here are two versions - a beautiful choral version and Ray Charles' soulful and moving one. My vote is cast; how about yours?
Photos © 2012 by A. Roy Hilbinger